In another decisive win for independent pharmacies, Health Law Alliance successfully overturned more than $30,000 in alleged inventory discrepancy findings asserted by Express Scripts’ Special Investigations Unit (SIU) against a Texas pharmacy. This outcome underscores the critical importance of experienced legal representation when navigating PBM audits, particularly those involving complex inventory and billing issues.
Express Scripts (ESI) initiated a Fraud, Waste, and Abuse (FWA) investigation under Section 5.8 of its Provider Manual, alleging significant inventory shortages and NDC-level discrepancies within the pharmacy’s reconciliation records. After the pharmacy engaged Health Law Alliance, the firm’s audit defense team conducted a meticulous review of the findings, supplier records, and dispensing data.
Following extensive correspondence and multiple evidentiary submissions on behalf of the pharmacy, ESI issued an updated Final Discrepancy Evaluation Report fully resolving its prior allegations related to inventory discrepancies. The final determination acknowledged that all previously identified inventory shortages had been fully reconciled and remedied. This result effectively reversed more than $30,000 in alleged inventory discrepancies, sparing the pharmacy from unwarranted recoupment.
Inventory discrepancy findings remain among the most common, and most perilous, issues raised during PBM audits. Even minor reconciliation variances can prompt allegations of billing irregularities or FWA. In this case, ESI’s initial conclusions were based on incomplete data that failed to capture delayed wholesaler reporting. Without timely and strategic intervention, these errors could have resulted in tens of thousands of dollars in financial exposure for the pharmacy.
The successful reversal of more than $30,000 in alleged findings demonstrates the importance of responding to PBM audits with precision and strategy. Thorough supplier documentation, coupled with legal advocacy attuned to both contractual nuances and regulatory frameworks, can transform what appears to be a losing audit into a victory.
This case illustrates the power of evidence-based legal defense, a cornerstone of Health Law Alliance’s audit strategy. By combining deep industry knowledge with exhaustive documentary analysis, the firm overturned inflated findings and prevented a substantial and unjustified recoupment.
How Health Law Alliance Can Help
Health Law Alliance represents pharmacies nationwide in PBM audits, PBM network terminations, and regulatory enforcement actions. When facing an audit, timing and strategy are everything. Whether your pharmacy is responding to a PBM audit, contesting a termination, or proactively strengthening its compliance protocols, Health Law Alliance delivers the expertise and results that make a difference. Contact us today for a free legal consultation.
MORE ARTICLES BY CATEGORY
PBM Enforcement Trends Independent Pharmacies Must Prepare for in 2026
Independent pharmacies are heading into 2026 under tighter PBM oversight, more aggressive audit practices, and evolving reimbursement models driven by regulatory pressure and DIR fee reform. To survive in this environment, pharmacies must strengthen compliance, documentation, and inventory controls while partnering with experienced PBM counsel to manage audits, protect reimbursements, and avoid network termination.
Read More >>PBM Audit Triggers: Understanding How Prescription Activity Is Evaluated
Pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) increasingly use data analytics and algorithmic surveillance to identify “red flag” prescriptions and atypical dispensing patterns, which can trigger audits, recoupments, network terminations, and payment withholds for independent pharmacies. By understanding common PBM risk indicators and implementing strong compliance practices, internal audits, documentation, and timely legal support, pharmacies can reduce exposure and more effectively defend themselves during PBM reviews and appeals.
Read More >>Health Law Alliance Successfully Reverses OptumRx’s Network Termination for a Michigan Pharmacy
We are proud to announce that the Health Law Alliance has successfully reversed a network termination from OptumRx for a Michigan-based independent pharmacy.
Read More >>What to Expect in a Wound Care Audit - And Why You Shouldn’t Go It Alone
In 2025, wound care audits have become a top enforcement priority for federal and private payors, leaving providers unprepared and facing thousands in recoupments. Understanding how wound care audits progress is crucial to defending your practice from unjust penalties, and engaging counsel early is essential to protecting your practice. Learn how Health Law Alliance can help prepare a strategy-driven defense designed to minimize risk and preserve your practice’s reputation.
Read More >>
